A Brief History of the Scottish Parliament
By Dr. Alan MacDonald, Dr. Alastair Mann and Dr. Roland Tanner
The Scottish Parliament, like other such institutions, evolved during the middle ages
from the king’s council of bishops and earls. It is perhaps first identifiable as a
parliament in 1235, described as a ‘colloquium’ and already with a political and
judicial role. By the early fourteenth century the attendance of knights and
freeholders had become important, and from 1326 burgh commissioners attended.
Consisting of the ‘three estates’ of clerics, lay tenants-in-chief and burgh
commissioners sitting in a single chamber, the Scottish Parliament acquired
significant powers over particular issues. Most obviously it was needed for consent
for taxation (although taxation was only raised irregularly in Scotland), but it also
had a strong influence over justice, foreign policy, war, and all manner of other
legislation, whether political, ecclesiastical, social or economic. Parliamentary
business was also carried out by ‘sister’ institutions, before c. 1500 by ‘General
Council’ and thereafter by the ‘Convention of Estates’. These could carry out
much business also dealt with by parliament - taxation, legislation and
policy-making - but lacked the ultimate authority of a full parliament.
The Lords of the Articles
During much of its history, a great deal of business in the Scottish Parliament was
carried out by the ‘Lords of the Articles’. This was a committee chosen by the
three estates to draft legislation which was then presented to the full assembly to
be confirmed. In the past historians have been particularly critical of this body,
claiming that it quickly came to be dominated by royal nominees, and thus
undermining the power of the full assembly. Recent research suggests that this
was far from always being the case, at least during the fifteenth century. Indeed, in
March 1482 the committee was taken over by men shortly to be involved in a coup
d’etat against the king and his government.
The Fifteenth Century
Parliament was often willing to defy the king—it was far from being simply a
‘rubber stamp’ of royal decisions. During the fifteenth century parliament was
called far more often than, for instance, the English Parliament—on average over
once a year—a fact that both reflected and augmented its influence. It repeatedly
opposed James I’s (1424-1437) requests for taxation to pay an English ransom in
the 1420s, and was openly hostile to James III (1460-1488) in the 1470s and early
1480s. In 1431 parliament granted a tax to James I for a campaign in the highlands
on the condition that it be kept in a locked chest under the keepership of figures
deeply out of favour with the king. In 1436 there was even an attempt made to
arrest the king ‘in the name of the three estates’.
Between October 1479 and
March 1482 parliament was conclusively out of the control of the James III. It
refused to forfeit his brother, the duke of Albany, despite a royal siege of the
duke’s castle, tried to prevent the king leading his army against the English (a
powerful indication of the estates’ lack of faith in their monarch), and appointed
men to the Lords of the Articles and important offices who were shortly to remove
the king from power. James IV (1488-1513), realised that parliament could often
create more problems than it solved, and avoided meetings after 1509. This was a
trend seen in other European nations as monarchical power grew stronger—for
instance England under Henry VII, France and some of the Spanish cortes.
The Sixteenth Century
During the sixteenth century the composition of parliament underwent a number of
significant changes and it found itself sharing the stage with new national bodies.
The emergence of the Convention of Royal Burghs as the ‘parliament’ of
Scotland’s trading towns and the development of the Kirk’s General Assembly
after the Reformation (1560) meant that rival representative assemblies could bring
pressure to bear on parliament in specific areas.
Following the Reformation, laymen acquired the monasteries and those sitting as
‘abbots’ and ‘priors’ were now, effectively, part of the estate of nobles. The
bishops continued to sit in parliament regardless of whether they conformed to
protestantism or not. This resulted in pressure from the Kirk to reform
ecclesiastical representation in parliament. Catholic clergy were excluded after
1567 but protestant bishops continued as the clerical estate until their abolition in
1638 when parliament became an entirely lay assembly. An act of 1587 granted
the lairds of each shire the right to send two commissioners to every parliament.
These shire commissioners attended from 1592 onwards, although they shared one
vote until 1640 when they secured a vote each. The number of burghs with the
right to send commissioners to parliament increased quite markedly in the late
sixteenth and early seventeenth centuries until, in the 1640s, they often constituted
the largest single estate in parliament.
The Seventeenth Century
In the second half of the sixteenth century, parliament began to legislate on more
and more matters and there was a marked increase in the amount of legislation it
produced. During the reign of James VI, the Lords of the Articles came heavily
under the influence of the crown. By 1612, they seem to have been appointed by
the crown rather than parliament, the independence of which was seriously eroded.
This decline was reversed in the Covenanting period (1638-51), when the Scottish
parliament took control of the executive, effectively wresting sovereignty from the
king and setting many precedents for the constitutional changes undertaken in
England soon afterwards. The Covenanting regime fell in 1651 after Scotland was
invaded by Oliver Cromwell whose Commonwealth government imposed a brief
Anglo-Scottish parliamentary union in 1657.
The Scottish Parliament returned after the Restoration of Charles II to the throne
in 1660, and, although initially docile, gradually came to exert considerable influence
over the Crown—removing the clergy’s right to attend in 1689 and finally
abolishing the Lords of the Articles in 1690. Parliament’s strength was such that
the Crown turned to corruption and political management to undermine its
autonomy. Nonetheless, the period from 1690 to 1707 was one in which political
‘parties’ and alliances were formed within parliament in a maturing atmosphere of
rigorous debate. It is an oversimplification to claim, as Robert Burns memorably
did, that the Union of England and Scotland (and hence the dissolution of the
Scottish Parliament) was brought about by the members being ‘bought and sold for
English gold’, nevertheless bribery, parliamentary division and wider economic
imperatives best explain the Crown’s ability to attain a majority in favour of
Incorporating Union with England.
The New Parliament
Almost three hundred years later, the Scottish Parliament has remained an
important element in Scottish national identity, and in September 1997 a referendum
of the Scottish electorate secured a large majority in favour of the establishment of
a new devolved Scottish Parliament in Edinburgh. An election was held in May
1999, and power was transferred from Westminster on 1 July 1999 to the new
Parliament in its temporary home in the General Assembly Hall on the Royal Mile.
This short gives the state of current thinking on the old Scottish Parliament. Yet
since Robert Rait’s Parliaments of Scotland was published in 1924, little detailed
research has been carried out on this topic until the last few years. The
establishment of the Scottish Parliament Project provides the opportunity for a new
research into all aspects and periods of Parliament’s history. Watch this space.
Further Reading
This article is copyright The
Scottish Parliament Project located at the University of St. Andrews, Scotland
A special thanks to Dr. Roland Tanner and the Scottish Parliament Project for permission to reprint this article.
Links: |
Thursday, December 26th, 2019
Attention visitors: Tartans.com is back. Please note that this is a snapshot of the site as it existed nearly 20 years ago and you may encounter broken links; we are still combing through the site and correcting those as we find them. Please also note that some sections are currently not functional, primarily the discussion forums/clan chat boards.
** HOME - First Time Visitors - Glossary - - Contact Us ** Awards | Bibliography | Clan Calendar | Clan Chat | Clan Finder | History | Famous Scots | Genealogy | Great Hall of the Clans | Links | News and Features | Scots on the Net | Search | Site Map The Gathering of the Clans Clans of Ireland | Ancestral Research Services Copyright 1995- Tartans.com - All Rights Reserved. |